Ninja Woodfire Outdoor Pizza
Current Model P Smart
When it comes to bringing restaurant-quality pizza home, the competition between smart electric ovens has never been hotter. Two standout contenders—the Ninja Woodfire Outdoor Pizza Oven and the Current Model P Smart Electric Pizza Oven—are redefining what’s possible in backyard and countertop cooking. Both promise fast, high-heat results with minimal fuss, but they take very different approaches to flavor, functionality, and versatility.
The Ninja Woodfire leans into its name by incorporating real wood smoke flavor using flavored pellets, while doubling as an 8-in-1 outdoor roaster capable of smoking ribs, roasting turkeys, and even dehydrating fruit. Meanwhile, the Current Model P Smart focuses on precision and convenience with app connectivity, a dual-pane viewing window, and blistering 850°F heat—all in a compact design that works indoors or out. Whether you’re a weekend griller, a pizza purist, or someone who loves tech-enhanced cooking, choosing between these two can feel overwhelming.
In this detailed comparison, we’ll break down every key feature, performance metric, and real-user experience to help you decide which oven fits your lifestyle. From heat output and cooking modes to ease of use and long-term durability, we’ve got you covered. By the end, you’ll know exactly which machine belongs on your patio—or your kitchen counter.
In-Depth Look: Ninja Woodfire Outdoor Pizza
The Ninja Woodfire Outdoor Pizza isn’t just a pizza oven—it’s a full-fledged outdoor kitchen powerhouse. Designed for those who want more than just margherita nights, this electric roaster delivers authentic wood-fired flavors without the hassle of charcoal or open flames. Thanks to its integrated pellet smoker box, you can infuse steaks, chicken, or even vegetables with that unmistakable smoky depth, all while hitting temperatures up to 700°F.
One of its standout features is the 8-in-1 functionality. Beyond pizza, it handles Max Roast, Specialty Roast, Broil, Bake, Smoker, Dehydrate, and Keep Warm modes. That means you can cook a 12-pound turkey, smoke a pork shoulder, or dry apple slices for snacks—all in one device. The included Pro-Heat Pan and pizza stone ensure even heat distribution, and the terracotta red finish gives it a stylish, rustic look that fits any backyard setup.
But it’s not just about versatility. The Ninja Woodfire excels at speed. With its 3-minute no-turn pizza capability (after preheating), you get charred crusts and bubbling cheese in record time. And because it’s electric, there’s no flame management or fuel monitoring—just plug in, select your setting, and let it do the work. It’s also built to withstand the elements, though Ninja recommends using their outdoor cover for long-term storage.
Pros:
– Real wood smoke flavor via pellet system
– Extremely versatile—great for roasting, smoking, baking
– Heats quickly and maintains consistent temps
– Weather-resistant construction
– Includes starter pellets and essential accessories
Cons:
– No viewing window (you must open the lid to check doneness)
– Requires outdoor use only (not suitable for indoor counters)
– Lower max temp than competitors (700°F vs. 850°F)
Customer Reviews Highlight:
> “I bought this for pizza and I love it. My pizzas are now nicely cooked on the bottom and perfect on the top with a wood smoke taste. Very easy to set up and easy learning curve. Looks smart. It heats up quickly. The sides do not get too hot to touch.”
> “After a delightful trip to New York, where we indulged in the city’s legendary pizzas, I was inspired to bring that flavor home. This oven did not disappoint—crispy crust, melty cheese, and that subtle smokiness makes all the difference.”
> “I bought this refurbished from Amazon… It was pristine. I can’t see any flaws… It cooks really well and uses only a handful of smoke pellets.”
Best For: Outdoor cooking enthusiasts, BBQ lovers, and families who want one device to handle pizza nights, holiday roasts, and weekend smoking sessions.
In-Depth Look: Current Model P Smart
If precision, convenience, and modern tech are your priorities, the Current Model P Smart is a compelling choice. This sleek, beige electric oven reaches an impressive 850°F—hotter than the Ninja—and does so without any wood, charcoal, or smoke. Instead, it relies on advanced electric heating elements to deliver restaurant-quality results in minutes, all while staying compact enough for indoor countertops.
What sets it apart is its smart app integration. Using your smartphone, you can monitor internal temperature, set custom timers, and even track cooking progress remotely. That’s especially handy if you’re multitasking or want to avoid overcooking your Neapolitan-style pie. The dual-pane viewing window is another win—it lets you watch your pizza bubble and crisp without losing heat by opening the door.
The eight cooking modes cover all the classics: Neapolitan, New York, Thin Crust, Frozen, and Broil, plus customizable options. Whether you’re reheating a store-bought pie or crafting a Detroit-style deep dish, the P Smart adapts quickly. Cleanup is straightforward too, thanks to smooth surfaces and removable components.
However, it’s not without flaws. Some users report that sauce or cheese dripping onto the heating elements can cause smoke indoors—so it’s best used near a vent or hood. More concerning is a design issue noted in reviews: the temperature sensors are made of glass, which may crack under extreme heat or accidental contact. While performance is generally excellent, this could affect long-term durability.
Pros:
– Highest max temperature (850°F) for ultra-crispy crusts
– App connectivity for remote monitoring and control
– Dual-pane window for safe, heat-efficient viewing
– Compact and safe for indoor/outdoor use
– Fast heat-up and consistent performance
Cons:
– No real wood smoke flavor (electric-only heating)
– Glass temperature sensors may be fragile
– Can produce smoke indoors if drippings hit elements
Customer Reviews Highlight:
> “This oven makes fantastic pizza. I use this oven outside and think that to use indoors it would need to be near a hood. It can create a lot of smoke if any sauce or cheese ends up on the stone. Presets for NY pizza work very well.”
> “If you can buy this on sale ($499, cyber deal) it’s worth it. Fast heat-up, easy to use and excellent design. I bought a 1lb dough ball at the supermarket and cut it in half to make 2 12–13 inch pizzas. Very fast and delicious.”
> “Although the oven performs really well and cooks food to perfection, there are three temperature sensors inside the oven which are made of glass! Unbelievably poor choice of material for an oven that goes to 850F.”
Best For: Tech-savvy home cooks, apartment dwellers, and anyone who values convenience, speed, and indoor usability—without needing smoky flavors.
Head-to-Head Comparison
Performance & Heat Output
The Current Model P Smart holds a clear edge in raw heat, reaching 850°F compared to the Ninja’s 700°F. That extra 150 degrees translates to faster charring and better blistering on crusts—ideal for authentic Neapolitan-style pizza. However, the Ninja compensates with its pellet system, adding depth of flavor that pure electric heating can’t replicate.
Versatility
Here, the Ninja dominates. While both offer multiple cooking modes, the Woodfire’s ability to roast large meats, smoke BBQ, and dehydrate foods makes it a true multi-tool. The P Smart is focused almost exclusively on pizza and similar high-heat tasks.
Ease of Use & Convenience
The P Smart wins for everyday simplicity. Its app control and viewing window reduce guesswork, and its compact size fits easily on counters. The Ninja requires outdoor setup and pellet management, which adds steps—but rewards with richer flavors.
Indoor vs. Outdoor Use
If you plan to cook indoors, the P Smart is your only option. The Ninja is strictly outdoor-only, making it less practical for urban users or those without patios.
Value for Money
Both hover around $499–$599, but the Ninja includes pellets, a smoker box, and more accessories out of the box. The P Smart offers cutting-edge tech but may require additional purchases (like a hood fan) for indoor safety.
Frequently Asked Questions
Q: Can I use the Ninja Woodfire Outdoor Pizza indoors?
A: No—this oven is designed for outdoor use only. It produces smoke and requires ventilation, so it’s not safe for indoor counters. If you need indoor capability, consider the Current Model P Smart instead.
Q: Does the Current Model P Smart actually taste like wood-fired pizza?
A: Not exactly. While it mimics the high heat of wood ovens, it lacks real smoke flavor. For that authentic char and aroma, the Ninja Woodfire with its pellet system is the better choice.
Q: Which oven is easier to clean?
A: The P Smart has smoother surfaces and removable parts, making wipe-downs quicker. The Ninja’s pellet box and larger interior require more attention, especially after smoking.
Q: Can I cook anything besides pizza in these ovens?
A: Absolutely! The Ninja excels at roasting meats, baking casseroles, and even dehydrating. The P Smart is more pizza-focused but can broil steaks or reheat leftovers.
Q: Is the app for the P Smart reliable?
A: Most users report smooth connectivity and accurate temp readings. Just ensure your phone is nearby during cooking for best results.
Q: Do I need special pellets for the Ninja?
A: The Ninja includes an All-Purpose Blend starter pack, but you can buy additional flavored pellets (hickory, apple, etc.) for varied smoke profiles.
Q: Which oven heats up faster?
A: Both heat quickly, but the P Smart reaches 850°F slightly faster due to higher wattage. However, the Ninja’s 25-minute preheat (excluded from cook times) should be factored in.
Final Verdict: Which One Should You Choose?
Choosing between the Ninja Woodfire Outdoor Pizza and the Current Model P Smart ultimately comes down to your cooking style and environment.
Go with the Ninja Woodfire Outdoor Pizza if you love smoky flavors, host frequent backyard gatherings, and want one device to handle pizza, roasts, and BBQ. It’s built for outdoor adventurers who value versatility and authenticity over tech bells and whistles.
Pick the Current Model P Smart if you prioritize speed, smart features, and indoor convenience. It’s perfect for city dwellers, tech lovers, and anyone who wants perfect pizza fast—without stepping outside.
Both are excellent in their own right. But only one will truly feel like your oven. So ask yourself: Do you crave smoke—or simplicity? Flavor—or function? Once you know, the choice becomes clear.
Ready to upgrade your pizza game? Click below to grab your ideal oven today.
